Skip to main content
burger and onion rings

Online Ordering Now Available

Place your order on our website and pick it up at our restaurant! Try it today!

Order Now
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 5/1.
Settler's Family Restaurant
  • Order Now
    Order Pickup DoorDash
  • Menu
  • Reservations
  • Gift Cards
  • Join Our Team
  • Contact
western burger

Main

Become a VIPReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Main

Settler's Salads

Add Grilled Pita or Garlic Bread for $0.99 | Add a Cup of Soup $1.99. Try one of our House Made Dressings: Bleu Cheese | Ranch | Italian | Greek.

Settler's Greek Souvlaki Salad
00000

Settler's Greek Souvlaki Salad

$10.99Salad topped with onions, peppers, tomato, cucumber, olives, feta cheese. Choice of chicken or beef souvlaki. Served with our house Greek Dressing

00000
Order Online
Santa Fe Chicken Salad
00000

Santa Fe Chicken Salad

$10.99Taco seasoned chicken, greens topped with black beans, roasted corn, tomato, cheddar cheese and tortilla chips, served with salsa ranch

00000
Order Online
00000

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$10.99Crisp mixed greens topped with Buffalo chicken fingers, tomato, cheddar and bleu cheese crumbles, served with celery sticks and House Made Bleu Cheese dressing

00000
Order Online
00000

Caesar Salad

$10.99Fresh cut Romaine lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing with choice of steak or chicken, croutons and Parmesan cheese

00000
Order Online
00000

Endless Soup & Salad

$14.99(Dine-in only ) Homemade soup with a side salad and dressing of choice

00000
00000

Monsoon Salad

$10.99Fresh spring greens with walnuts, almonds, mandarin oranges, craisins and sliced chicken, served with poppyseed dressing

00000
Order Online
00000

Chef Salad

$10.99Salad greens topped with turkey, ham, Swiss and American Cheese, tomato and a hard boiled egg

00000
Order Online
00000

Harvest Chicken Salad

$10.99Salad greens topped with sliced chicken breast, bleu cheese crumbles, Gala apples and walnuts, served with raspberry vinaigrette

00000
Order Online
00000

Pittsburg Salad

$10.99Greens topped with sliced sirloin steak or chicken breast, tomato, onions, French fries and cheddar cheese, served with sweet & sour Riviera dressing

00000
Order Online

Wraps & Pitas

Wrap choices: Garlic or Plain. Served with choice of potato.

Chicken Cranberry
00000

Chicken Cranberry

$10.49Grilled chicken breast, sliced almonds, dried cranberries, cheddar cheese, lettuce and Riviera dressing

00000
Order Online
00000

Bacon Cheeseburger

$10.49Cheeseburger with onions, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise

00000
Order Online
Chicken Cordon Bleu
00000

Chicken Cordon Bleu

$10.49Chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, ham and Swiss cheese

00000
Order Online
00000

Cold Cut

$9.99Choice of turkey, ham, roast beef, tuna salad or BLT with lettuce, tomato, bacon, American cheese and mayonnaise

00000
Order Online
Buffalo Chicken
00000

Buffalo Chicken

$10.49Buffalo fingers with cheddar, bacon, tomato, lettuce and bleu cheese

00000
Order Online
00000

Souvlaki

$10.49Chicken or Beef with lettuce, tomato, onions, feta and Tzatziki sauce

00000
Order Online
00000

Steak & Three Cheese

$10.49Shaved steak tossed with sautéed peppers and onions, cheddar, mozzarella and American cheeses

00000
Order Online

Old School Sandwiches

Served with potato chips. Add a cup of soup or side salad $1.99

Club Sandwich
10010

Club Sandwich

$8.99Choice of turkey, ham, roast beef, tuna or BLT served on white toast with lettuce, tomato, bacon and mayonnaise

10010
Order Online
00000

Grilled Cheese

$4.99With American cheese, choice of ham or bacon

00000
Order Online
Western Sandwich
00000

Western Sandwich

$5.991 scrambled egg with onions, peppers, ham and cheese on white buttered toast

00000
Order Online
00000

Cold Sub

$9.99Choice of turkey, ham, roast beef, tuna or BLT on French bread with lettuce, tomato, bacon, American cheese and mayonnaise

00000
Order Online
00000

Zwiegles Red Hot

$4.99On a toasted roll

00000
Order Online
00000

Egg Salad Sandwich

$5.49Egg salad, made to order, on white bread with lettuce

00000
Order Online
00000

Deli Sandwich

$6.99Choose from turkey, ham, roast beef, tuna salad, or BLT, on white bread with lettuce and mayonnaise

00000
Order Online

Melts

Served with Tater Tots. Add a Cup of Soup or Side Salad $1.99

Buffalo Chicken Melt
00000

Buffalo Chicken Melt

$10.49Buffalo chicken fingers, tomato and cheddar on grilled French bread

00000
Order Online
Turkey Melt
10001

Turkey Melt

$10.49Warm, sliced turkey on grilled sourdough with bacon and American cheese

10001
Order Online
00000

Four Cheese Grilled Cheese

$9.49Swiss, Mozzarella, Cheddar and American cheeses - all on grilled sourdough

00000
Order Online
00000

Batavia Melt

$10.49Shaved steak, Buffalo sauce, jalapeños, mushrooms, and Mozzarella, all on grilled sourdough

00000
Order Online
00000

The Pickle Back!

$9.49Crispy grilled cheese with dill pickles, bacon, American cheese - all on grilled sourdough

00000
Order Online
00000

Chicken Souvlaki Melt

$10.49On grilled Texas toast with feta cheese, tomato, bacon and Tzatziki sauce

00000
Order Online
00000

Bacon Bacon Melt

$10.49Grilled cheese on sourdough with tomato, loaded with crispy bacon

00000
Order Online

Classic Hot Sandwiches

Served with choice of potato. Add a cup of soup or side salad $1.99

00000

Beef on Kimmelweck

$10.49Slow roasted choice top sirloin on a kimmelweck roll, dipped in au jus

00000
Order Online
Settler's Chicken Supreme
00000

Featured

Settler's Chicken Supreme

$10.49Chicken breast on a roll dressed with Swiss cheese and bacon

00000
Order Online
00000

Hot Roast Beef

$10.49On white bread with gravy

00000
Order Online
00000

Hot Meatloaf

$10.49On white bread with gravy

00000
Order Online
Mr. Reuben
00000

Mr. Reuben

$10.49Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and corned beef or turkey on grilled rye

00000
Order Online
00000

Grilled Tuna

$10.49Tuna on grilled rye with American cheese and tomato

00000
Order Online
Hot Turkey
00000

Hot Turkey

$10.49On white bread with gravy

00000
Order Online
French Dip
00000

French Dip

$10.49Roast beef dipped in au jus sauce on a grilled hoagie roll

00000
Order Online

Hot Subs

Served with choice of potato. Add a cup of soup or side salad $1.99

Philly Steak
00000

Featured

Philly Steak

$10.49Shaved steak topped with fried onions and peppers, topped with cheese sauce and served on grilled French bread

00000
Order Online
00000

Italian Sausage Sub

$10.49Italian sausage dressed with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and American cheese on grilled French bread

00000
Order Online
Chicken Parmesan
00000

Chicken Parmesan

$10.49On grilled French bread with sauce and Mozzarella

00000
Order Online
00000

Cheeseburger Sub

$10.49Grilled cheeseburger on a grilled French bread with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and bacon

00000
Order Online
00000

Chicken Finger Sub

$10.49Buffalo sauce, BBQ or plain on grilled French bread with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and American cheese

00000
Order Online

Burger Specialties

All steak burgers served with choice of potato. Add cup of soup or side salad $1.99

00000

Build Your Own Burger

$10.49Start off with a 6 oz. steak burger, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and cheese. (Please, no substitutions on those toppings). Choose Your Bread: Roll | Wrap | Pita | White | Wheat | Rye | Sourdough | Texas. Choose One Topping: Bacon | Mushrooms | Onions | Roasted Red Peppers | Bleu Cheese Crumbles | Jalapeños | BBQ Sauce | Onion Rings | Pickles. Each additional topping $0.49. If you don't see your topping, just ask!

00000
Order Online
Western Burger
00000

Western Burger

$10.496 oz. steak burger topped with bacon, onion rings, BBQ sauce, and cheddar cheese

00000
Order Online
Tavern Burger
00000

Featured

Tavern Burger

$10.49Grilled 6 oz. Steak Burger seasoned with Montreal steak seasoning, sautéed onions and mushrooms, with a dab of cheddar cheese sauce on a grilled French bread

00000
Order Online
00000

Settler Burger

$10.496 oz. Steak Burger topped with sautéed mushrooms and onions, Mozzarella cheese and bacon on a roll or grilled sourdough

00000
Order Online
Sky Burger
10001

Sky Burger

$11.49Two 6 oz. burgers dressed with bacon & American cheese

10001
Order Online

Lighter Fare

Add a cup of soup or a side salad for $1.99

00000

Quiche of the Day

$7.49Ask your server. Served with tomato slices, side of vegetable and cottage cheese

00000
Order Online
00000

Grilled Chicken

$10.49Served with Korean BBQ seasoned quinoa and brown rice blend and side vegetable

00000
Order Online
00000

1/2 Deli Sandwich

$7.991/2 Deli sandwich served with potato chips and a cup of soup

00000
Order Online
00000

Ground Beef Patty

$10.49Char-broiled and served with cottage cheese, tomato slices, and side vegetable

00000
Order Online
Settler's Greek Chicken Flatbread
00000

Settler's Greek Chicken Flatbread

$10.49Crispy flatbread with a spread of Tzatziki sauce, topped with house chicken souvlaki, feta cheese and spinach, finished with diced, fresh tomato and onion

00000
Order Online

Entrées

Served with soup or a side salad & potato

Asian Grilled Salmon
00000

Featured

Asian Grilled Salmon

$15.49Asian spice rubbed grilled salmon on a bed of Korean BBQ seasoned quinoa and brown rice blend. Choice of potato

00000
Order Online
00000

Fried Shrimp Basket

$13.99Lightly breaded shrimp fried golden brown. Served with cocktail or tartar sauce. Choice of potato

00000
Order Online
00000

Fried Chicken

$13.994 golden brown pieces of chicken, fried crispy. Choice of potato

00000
Order Online
00000

Smothered Chicken Dinner

$13.992 chicken breasts smothered with peppers, fried onions, mushrooms, cheddar and Mozzarella. Choice of potato

00000
Order Online
00000

Stuffed Shells

$12.994 stuffed shells topped with homemade sauce and melted Mozzarella. Served with garlic bread (no potato choice)

00000
Order Online
00000

Roast Turkey Dinner

$13.99Fresh roast turkey over homemade stuffing, topped with gravy. Roast beef upon request. Choice of potato

00000
Order Online
00000

Settler's Liver & Onions

$12.99The best liver topped with fried onions, peppers and bacon. Choice of potato

00000
Order Online
Meatloaf "Italiano"
00000

Meatloaf "Italiano"

$14.992 slices of our homemade meatloaf topped with sauce and Mozzarella cheese. Served with pasta (no potato choice)

00000
Order Online
Mount Olympus Meat Loaf
00000

Featured

Mount Olympus Meat Loaf

$14.992 generous portions of homemade meat loaf piled high on top of mashed potatoes smothered with gravy, (no potato choice)

00000
Order Online
00000

Seared Scallops

$15.49Seared scallops with your choice of Asian, Cajun, or Lemon Pepper. Choice of potato

00000
Order Online
00000

Broiled Fish Dinner

$13.99Your choice of Asian, Cajun or Lemon Pepper. Choice of potato

00000
Order Online
00000

Fried Clam Strips Basket

$13.99Lightly breaded clams fried golden brown. Served with cocktail or tartar sauce. Choice of potato

00000
Order Online
Strip Steak
00000

Featured

Strip Steak

$16.9910 oz. N.Y. strip steak topped off with sautéed mushrooms and onions. Choice of potato

00000
Order Online
Parmesan Dinner
00000

Parmesan Dinner

$14.99Chicken breaded and fried, topped with Mozzarella and sauce, served with pasta (no potato choice)

00000
Order Online
11000

Fish Fry

$13.99Beer battered and deep fried golden brown. Breaded upon request. Choice of potato

11000
Order Online
Roast Beef Tower
00000

Roast Beef Tower

$13.99Garlic bread topped with mashed potatoes, roast beef, crispy bacon, gravy, then broiled with cheddar cheese (no potato choice)

00000
Order Online
Bourbon Chicken Stir Fry
00000

Bourbon Chicken Stir Fry

$14.99Chicken breast, broccoli, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, all stir fried together with bourbon sauce and served over house rice. (no potato choice)

00000
Order Online
Greek Souvlaki Dinner
00000

Greek Souvlaki Dinner

$13.99Choice of chicken souvlaki or beef souvlaki meat over rice with a Greek salad and house dressing. Served with garlic or pita bread (no potato choice or side salad)

00000
Order Online
00000

Settlers Pasta Dinner

$13.99Served with 2 meatballs or 1 Italian sausage. (no potato choice)

00000
Order Online

Mac & Cheese Favorites

Add a cup of soup or side salad $1.99

00000

Featured

Homemade Mac & Cheese

Homemade macaroni and cheese topped with a blend of crushed Ritz crackers and cheese, baked in our own broilerFull $12.99Half $10.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Philly Mac

$14.99Our homemade mac & cheese with shaved steak, mushrooms, onions, peppers and our crumb topping

00000
Order Online
00000

All-American Mac & Cheese

$14.99Chopped steak burger with crispy bacon and tomato, all mixed together in our homemade mac & cheese and topped with our crumb topping

00000
Order Online
00000

Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese

$14.99Our homemade mac & cheese with diced chicken fingers, bleu cheese crumbles, hot sauce and tomatoes, topped with our crumb topping

00000
Order Online
00000

Seafood Mac

$15.99Crab meat, shrimp and scallops, all tossed in our homemade mac & cheese, and finished with our crumb topping

00000
Order Online
10001

Stinger Mac

$14.99Grilled, chopped chicken breast, bacon, and chopped jalapeños, all tossed in our homemade mac & cheese and topped with our crumb topping

10001
Order Online

Sides

00000

Soup

Cup $3.99Bowl $4.49Quart $10

00000
Order Online
00000

Potato Salad

$3.99seasonal

00000
Order Online
00000

Tater Tots

$3.99

00000
Order Online
10010

Sweet Potato Fries

$3.99

10010
Order Online
00000

Mashed Potatoes

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Baked Potato

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Garlic Bread

$2.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Coleslaw

$2.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Fruit Cup

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Macaroni Salad

$3.99seasonal

00000
Order Online
00000

Onion Rings

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

French Fries

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Potato Wedges

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Macaroni & Cheese

$6.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Side Salad

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Pita Bread

$2.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Vegetable

$1.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Korean BBQ Seasoned Quinoa

$4.99

00000
Order Online

18% Gratuity added to tables of 8 or more

When you support a small business, you're supporting a dream

"We would like to thank this beautiful community for its continued support of our Family Restaurant, and also thank our hard-working staff. You all hold a special place in our hearts" Spyropoulos Family

Made with by Popmenu
Settler's Family Restaurant
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window